<!-- Canonical: https://myoctopus.ai/technical/deterministic-vs-probabilistic-financial-calculation -->

# Deterministic vs probabilistic calculation in finance AI

A language model samples tokens. Two identical questions can return two different numbers. That property is acceptable for drafting and unacceptable for a reported figure.

The design question is not whether to use a model but where the deterministic boundary sits. In Octopus AI, everything numeric sits on the deterministic side.

Each AFI capability documents that boundary in its published system card, so a model-risk reviewer can see exactly what the model does and does not do.

## Questions and answers

### What runs deterministically?

Reconciliation, consolidation, currency conversion, variance arithmetic, threshold evaluation, and forecast rebasing. All of it is code executed against reconciled source data.

### What does the language model do?

Language only: reading a question, drafting a request for commentary, and explaining a computed result in plain words. It never originates a figure.

### Why does this matter for SR 11-7?

SR 11-7 model risk centres on a model's output driving decisions. When arithmetic is deterministic code, model drift or a version change cannot alter a reported number, which narrows the model-risk surface to language behaviour.

### Is a deterministic system less capable?

It is differently capable. Determinism removes generated arithmetic, not automation. The initiating workflow — detecting a variance, contacting the owner, logging the answer, rebasing the forecast — remains autonomous.

### How is the boundary verified rather than asserted?

By reproducibility and lineage: the same inputs return the same figure, and every figure traces to source line items. Both are testable without access to model internals.

## Proof

*   Reference client: $523K total contract value over 3 years.
*   Approximately 430 analyst hours saved.
*   Forecast cycle cut from about 60 hours to under 6 hours (90% faster).
*   Error rate below 0.1%.
*   2,500+ autonomous tasks completed in month one.

## Related pages

*   [Octopus AI vs Anaplan](/vs/anaplan)
*   [Model system cards](/trust/system-cards)
*   [All technical briefs](/technical)
